Is Your Vote Still Safe? The Election Commission, Voter Fraud, and the Democracy on the Brink

Rahul Gandhi flagged the Maharashtra Assembly elections as a glaring example of electoral irregularities. He alleged that between the Lok Sabha and Vidhan Sabha polls, there was an unexplained surge of over one crore new voters—a number he called “absurd” and even exceeding the actual population growth of the state. Adding to the suspicion, he pointed out a dramatic spike in voter turnout after 5:30 PM, which he believes was never properly explained.

He also accused the Election Commission of obstructing transparency, saying it refused to provide the voter list in a machine-readable format, making proper auditing by opposition parties nearly impossible. “This list is the property of the people, not the BJP,” Gandhi asserted, claiming the EC’s secrecy raises serious doubts about its impartiality.

Most controversially, he said the EC had decided to destroy CCTV footage from polling stations, which could have been vital in investigating the unusual turnout patterns. “Instead of answering questions, the Commission is erasing the evidence,” he said, calling it a clear act of shielding wrongdoing. Gandhi maintained that these actions suggest deliberate collusion between the EC and the BJP, with democracy itself at stake.

Calling the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls an “institutionalised chori,” Rahul Gandhi, accused the Election Commission of “openly colluding” with the BJP to systematically strip the poor of their voting rights through deliberate voter list manipulation.

BJP’s Rebuttal: Counterattack in Full Swing

After Rahul Gandhi alleged “a huge criminal fraud” in the 2024 Lok Sabha elections, particularly in Bangalore Central, accusing the BJP and Election Commission (EC), the BJP hit back strongly, dismissing the claims as baseless and a deliberate attempt to discredit constitutional institutions.

Union Minister Kiren Rijiju said Congress attacks institutions like the EC and judiciary when outcomes don’t favour them, pointing out that the same electoral rolls helped them win in Maharashtra. Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan called Gandhi “Bayan Bahadur” and suggested a larger conspiracy behind Congress’s attacks on democracy. BJP spokesperson Sambit Patra questioned why Congress wasn’t raising similar concerns in states it won. Ravi Shankar Prasad termed Gandhi’s remarks “irresponsible and shameless,” claiming the public continues to reject such conduct.

Mobile Voting: Innovation or Invitation to Manipulation?

Parallel to these allegations, a new technological frontier was unfolding in Bihar. In what was hailed as a revolutionary move, the state introduced e-voting via mobile applications during the recent by-elections.

Historical Echoes: From Booth Capturing to Digital Rigging

India’s tryst with electoral fraud is not new. From booth capturing in the 1970s and 80s, where armed goons would hijack polling booths, to the alleged EVM tampering debates of the 2000s, the Indian electoral process has often been marred by shadowy practices.

However, recent developments signal a shift from brute force to stealthy tech-based manipulation.

• Booth's capturing was visible and violent.
• Voter roll manipulation and digital fraud are silent and systemic—leaving little trace but significant impact.

This evolution makes it harder for courts and observers to detect electoral malpractice and poses an existential challenge to democratic fairness.

The Role of the Election Commission: Watchdog or Toothless Tiger?

The ECI, enshrined under Article 324 of the Constitution, is meant to function as an independent constitutional authority. Its mandate includes ensuring free and fair elections, scrutinising political conduct, and safeguarding the integrity of voter rolls.

Yet, recent events have raised crucial concerns:

• Delayed Response: The EC’s reactions to major allegations have often been slow or defensive rather than investigatory.
• Technocratic Approach: Heavy reliance on data and digital verification without understanding on-ground socio-economic realities.
• Transparency Gap: Key electoral roll decisions, revisions, and deletions lack public audit trails or external oversight.

Can an institution that is increasingly defensive and opaque continue to command the trust of a billion citizens?

Future of Voting: Blockchain, VVPATs, and the Way Ahead

Technologists have suggested deploying blockchain-based voting systems, biometric encryption, and AI-aided audits to bring transparency to India’s elections. Academic papers have outlined pilot models where smart contracts and distributed ledgers can make every vote traceable and verifiable—without compromising secrecy.

The Supreme Court has already made VVPAT (Voter Verified Paper Audit Trail) mandatory in some polling stations to cross-verify EVM tallies. However, current VVPAT coverage remains woefully inadequate.

Without systemic reforms and public participation, such innovations risk becoming cosmetic rather than transformative.

What’s at Stake?

• Voter Disenfranchisement: When legitimate voters are erased or denied their franchise due to arbitrary documentation policies or flawed tech, democracy fails its weakest.
• Polarised Institutions: As the Election Commission becomes the subject of partisan debate, its neutrality and authority erode.
• Judicial Overload: More voters and parties are turning to the judiciary for electoral grievances, burdening courts with what should be administrative matters.
• Public Cynicism: With each allegation of fraud, citizens lose faith in voting—a dangerous trend in a democracy.

The Road Ahead: Questions We Must Ask

As the debate rages on, we must collectively address the following:

• Should voter lists be audited by an independent bipartisan committee, outside the EC?
• Can mobile voting be trusted in the absence of 100% voter identity verification and paper trails?
• Why are migrant workers—who form the economic backbone of India—treated as second-class voters?
• What reforms are needed to restore public trust in the ECI?

Conclusion: A Tipping Point for Democracy

India is standing at a democratic crossroads. On one side lies a path of reform, where technology is matched with accountability and transparency. On the other is a slippery slope—where silent manipulation, exclusion, and institutional compromise could lead to democratic decay.

References

[1] Rahul accuses EC, BJP of poll fraud: ‘1,00,250 votes stolen’ in a Karnataka seat, Available Here

[2] SIR 'institutionalised chori'; ECI colluding with BJP to carry out 'vote theft': Rahul, Available Here

[3] India’s First E-Voting App Usage in Bihar Sparks Voters’ Data Security & Privacy Concerns, Available Here

[4] Constitution of India, 1950

Important Link

Law Library: Notes and Study Material for LLB, LLM, Judiciary, and Entrance Exams