What are the formalities necessary for a valid gift by a Hindu, a Mohammedan and a Christian?

In Indian law, a "gift" is a voluntary transfer of property without any monetary consideration. While the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (TPA) governs the law relating to gifts generally, personal laws play a crucial role in determining the formalities of a valid gift depending on the religion of the donor and the donee. Hindus and Christians are governed largely by the TPA, while Muslims are governed by their personal laws. This distinction leads to differing requirements concerning the mode of execution, registration, and delivery of possession.

Gifts by Hindus

Hindus are subject to both the general provisions of the TPA and their personal law. As per Section 122 of the TPA, a gift must be made voluntarily and without consideration, and it must be accepted by the donee during the lifetime of the donor. For movable property, delivery of possession—either actual or constructive—is sufficient to constitute a valid gift.

However, for immovable property, Section 123 mandates that the gift must be executed by a registered instrument, signed by the donor and attested by at least two witnesses. Acceptance by the donee is necessary and must occur while the donor is still alive and capable of giving. If these conditions are not fulfilled, the gift is invalid in law.

Gifts by Muslims (Mohammedans)

In contrast to Hindus, Muslims are governed by Mohammedan Law in matters of gift (referred to as Hiba), and not by the TPA. Under Muslim law, a valid gift does not require a written document or registration, even for immovable property. Instead, three essential conditions must be fulfilled: (i) a clear declaration of the gift by the donor, (ii) acceptance of the gift by the donee, and (iii) delivery of possession of the subject matter of the gift. Possession must be given over physically or symbolically, and without this, the gift is considered incomplete.

While written instruments may be executed, they are not mandatory unless required for evidentiary purposes. The simplicity of the process under Muslim law distinguishes it sharply from the formal requirements under the TPA.

Gifts by Christians

Christians do not have a codified personal law dealing specifically with gifts; therefore, they are governed by the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. The legal formalities for a valid gift by a Christian are the same as those applicable to Hindus under the TPA. In the case of movable property, the gift can be effected through delivery of possession, and no registration is required.

However, in the case of immovable property, a valid gift must be made through a registered instrument signed by the donor and attested by at least two witnesses, as per Section 123 of the Act. The donee’s acceptance must take place during the lifetime of the donor, and the donor must be competent to give the gift at the time of the transfer.

Conclusion

Thus, the requirements for a valid gift vary significantly among Hindus, Muslims, and Christians. For Hindus and Christians, the TPA mandates formal execution and registration for immovable property and recognises delivery of possession for movables. On the other hand, Muslim law, while more flexible, demands strict compliance with the essential ingredients of a valid Hiba, particularly the delivery of possession. The legal framework ensures that, regardless of religious affiliation, gifts are executed with clarity of intention, acceptance, and lawful transfer of ownership.

• Property Law - Notes, Case Laws And Study Material
• Test Series for Competitions